What Is Behavioural Finance?What Is Behavioural Finance?
Behavioural finance is a field that combines the principles of psychology and economics to understand how human behaviour affects financial decisions and markets. It recognises that people are not always rational, and their emotions, biases, and cognitive errors can influence their financial choices.
Behavioural finance is a growing field of study that continues to gain recognition and influence in the sector. Researchers study how people process information, how they form expectations, and how they react to market events. In this FXOpen article, we will consider the cornerstones of behavioural finance theory.
Behavioural Finance Definition
Let’s start with the behavioural finance theory. Behavioural finance is the study of how psychological factors, such as emotions and biases, impact financial decision-making and market outcomes. It seeks to explain why people often deviate from rationality when making financial decisions and how these deviations lead to market fluctuations.
The emergence of behavioural finance can be traced back to the groundbreaking work of Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky in the 1970s. Today, big-name universities around the world continue to study the impact of different factors on decision-making in business, investing, and personal finance.
Understanding Economic Behaviour and Psychology
Behavioural finance recognises that economic behaviour is determined by more than rationality and self-interest. The study takes into account the following psychological factors:
Emotional influence. Emotions like fear, greed, and overconfidence lead a person to make irrational choices, e.g. adding funds to a losing trade or changing take-profit targets to cover more gains.
Behavioural financial biases. Many biases influence decision-making, for example, confirmation bias (favouring information that confirms pre-existing beliefs) and accessibility bias (overestimating the importance of readily available information).
Cognitive errors. People are prone to cognitive errors, such as overestimating their abilities or relying on heuristics (mental shortcuts) instead of careful analysis.
What Is Economic and Financial Heuristics?
Heuristics is the process by which people use mental shortcuts and simple strategies to quickly form judgements and make decisions. In the context of behavioural finance, economic and financial heuristics refer to cognitive shortcuts that simplify financial decision-making. The most common of them include:
Representativeness heuristic: judgments are based on similarity to a prototype or stereotype. For example, an investor may assume that a company with a well-known brand is a safer investment, even if there is no objective evidence to support this belief.
Availability heuristic: judgments rely on the ease with which relevant examples or information come to mind. For example, an investor may invest in a particular industry if they recently read positive news about it, even if the overall market conditions are unfavourable.
Anchoring heuristic: this involves individuals forming estimates by commencing from an initial value, often referred to as an "anchor." For example, an investor may anchor their price estimate for a stock based on its current market price, even if the fundamental factors suggest a different valuation.
If you are interested in the topic of trading psychology and want to learn more, explore our blog. We’ve posted several related articles you may like. We are happy to provide our clients with valuable insights that could help them gain new skills and knowledge.
Behavioural Finance Biases
As we mentioned, behavioural finance recognises that investors can be irrational and that their decisions can be influenced by biases. Here are some of the potential biases:
Self-attribution bias — traders attribute positive investment results to their own skills and blame negative results on external factors or bad luck.
Confirmation bias — people pay close attention to information that supports a financial or investment belief and disregard whatever contradicts it.
Framing bias — an investor reacts to a certain financial opportunity based on how it is presented. The way information is framed influences their choices.
Loss aversion — the fear of losing money may become a more powerful inhibitor for an investor; if it is, they won’t take risks and may miss out on potential profits.
Cognitive Errors
Apart from behavioural biases in finance, there are inefficient decisions that could be partially the result of cognitive errors. Cognitive distortions are rigid errors in thinking that grossly misinterpret events in harmful or negative ways. These patterns are full of assumptions and incorrect logic, while real-world evidence does not back them up. The most common errors include:
Filtering
Polarisation
Overgeneralisation
Discounting the positive
Hasty conclusions
Catastrophising
Everyone falls into cognitive distortions from time to time, but if you engage too frequently in negative thoughts, your mental health can take a hit.
Emotional Reasoning
Emotional reasoning refers to a cognitive mechanism through which a person arrives at the belief that their emotional reaction validates the truth of a statement or situation, even in the presence of contradictory evidence. Fear and greed are strong emotions that often drive people to make blind decisions. Fear can lead to panic selling during market downturns, while greed can lead to excessive risk-taking and speculative behaviour.
How Does Investor Behaviour Differ?
The frequent prejudices seen in investor behaviour are:
Herding — when investors follow the crowd and base their actions on what others do (buy, hold, or sell).
Overconfidence — when investors overestimate their abilities and believe they can consistently outperform the market.
How Does Trader Behaviour Differ?
Traders may be influenced by the following:
Momentum trading — when they follow trends and buy or sell based on recent price movements rather than fundamental analysis.
Overtrading — when traders engage in excessive buying and selling, driven by emotions like fear or greed.
Confirmation bias — when traders overvalue their pre-existing beliefs and ignore contradictory evidence.
Market Psychology
Market psychology is based on the emotional factors that influence the decisions of participants in financial markets. People's behaviour is often driven by their perceptions, beliefs, and expectations about the market and the economy. They are influenced by news events, economic data, and geopolitical developments. Let’s consider three common examples of market inefficiencies explained by psychology:
Market bubbles , when asset prices become detached from their underlying fundamentals, can be driven by herd behaviour and excessive optimism.
Market crashes , when assets lose value for no particular reason, can be triggered by panic selling and fear.
Market anomalies , such as the value premium or the momentum effect, suggest that investors deviate from rationality and create opportunities for profit. These anomalies cannot be explained by traditional studies but can be justified by behavioural finance theories.
Final Thoughts
In recent years, this field has gained momentum; for example, scientists exploring the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and the development of online services that influence consumer preferences. As this field evolves, it’s likely to have a significant impact on the way we think about investing and managing risk.
Technical analysis indicators may help traders overcome behavioural finance bias and base their decisions on price data and effective indicators and patterns that have been used by traders for years. To try them, you can use the FXOpen TickTrader platform. If you are ready to start trading, you can open an FXOpen account.
This article represents the opinion of the Companies operating under the FXOpen brand only. It is not to be construed as an offer, solicitation, or recommendation with respect to products and services provided by the Companies operating under the FXOpen brand, nor is it to be considered financial advice.
Behavioural
The 3 Dimension Trading / Investing 3D Investing or Trading = Technical Analysis + Depth Analysis
Depth Analysis:
• Macro analysis or / and
• Micro analysis or / and
• Other analysis
See the following video "3rd Dimension Analysis" link for other analysis.
Many use either technical or fundamental analysis alone in their research work, I observed they likely to struggle with confidence to make the entry judgement call. We can develop a greater confidence in how we time the market by combining TA + FA.
3 types of gold for trading:
• COMEX Gold
0.10 per troy ounce = $10.00
• E-mini Gold
0.25 per troy ounce = $12.50
• Micro Gold
0.10 per troy ounce = $1.00
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
CME Real-time Market Data help identify trading set-ups in real-time and express my market views. If you have futures in your trading portfolio, you can check out on CME Group data plans available that suit your trading needs www.tradingview.com
3rd Dimension Analysis. One dimension analysis or the depth analysis can be studying into the financial data of a the company.
. Two dimension analysis is when the investor or trader studying into the chart - Price & Time.
. Third dimension analysis is where we combine one and two dimension analysis.
Third Dimension Analysis = TA + Depth
Micro E-Mini Dow Jones
Contract value, $0.50 x DJIA Index
Micro E-Mini S&P
Contract value, $5 x S&P 500 Index
Micro E-Mini Nasdaq
Contract value, $2 x Nasdaq-100 Index
Micro E-Mini Russell
Contract value, $5 x Russell 2000 Index
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
CME Real-time Market Data help identify trading set-ups in real-time and express my market views. If you have futures in your trading portfolio, you can check out on CME Group data plans available that suit your trading needs www.tradingview.com
Limit and Market orders, cognitive & behavioral reviewWe assume a spot market for this article purely on the result of TRADES' interaction with no market making effect from the broker or exchange. You can only profit from buying at a lower price and selling at a higher price. So, there is no short in here. And we assume that you already know the basics of market and limit orders. As you can see the table on the chart for the whole idea, we want to talk a bit deeper.
Limit Orders
Limit Order is like a Wall, it makes liquidity on the order book to fill the market orders and that is why it is called MAKER.
In limit order, the price is more important than the time.
Limit order makes the market less volatile.
Market Orders
Market Order is like a Wrecking Ball, it takes liquidity from the order book and is filled from limit orders and that is why it is called TAKER.
In market order, the time is more important than the price.
Market order makes the market more volatile.
Now for both of these order types we have Buyers and Sellers.
Buyers always want to buy at lower price, and sellers always want to sell at higher price, so every limit buy should be lower than the current price and every limit sell should be higher than the current price.
If you put a buy limit order higher than the current price or a sell limit order lower than the current price, it will act as a TAKER order not a maker order.
If there is a buy market order at the same time with another sell market order, the buy market order is filled with the lowest sell limit order on the order book and the sell market order is filled with the highest buy limit order on the order book.
So, in every trade that is executed on the order book, one of the buyers or the sellers should be a market order and the other one should be a limit order. It's either the buyer is maker, and the seller is taker, or the buyer is taker, and the seller is maker. That's how the price moves!
Selling market orders push the price to go lower and buying market orders push the price to move higher.
Selling limit orders pull the price from going higher and buying limit orders pull the price from going lower.
Selling limit orders are more spread above the resistances BUT buying limit orders are more concrete at the support price.
Now let's talk about a few facts from Behavioral Finance !
1- Confirmation Bias
: the tendency to interpret new evidence as confirmation of one's existing beliefs or theories (like when the price is inside the ichimoku cloud). So, if I buy at any price, till a long time I will think that it will go higher! and this may be why a lot of people have big losses over time and do not commit to their stop loss.
2- Loss aversion or Prospect Theory : the tendency to prefer avoiding losses to acquiring equivalent gains. losses are twice as powerful, psychologically, as gains (like the urge feeling for revenge trading when you have lost in your last trade). This may be why people use Market orders for exiting from a position instead of Limit orders.
A graph of perceived value of gain or loss vs. strict numerical value of gain or loss.
3- Risk aversion : a preference for a sure outcome over a gamble with higher or equal expected value (like when you can enter at a better price but you rather to confirm your analysis sacrificing your potential profit). This may be why people (or maybe it is better to say good traders) use Limit Orders for entering at a position instead of market orders.
Now if someone buys at a high price and gets in loss, there is a conflict between Confirmation Bias and Loss aversion. If confirmation bias wins (which is for most of the people with lower experience), you just stay in the loss in the hope of a pivot point to sell at break even and that creates an additional sell pressure on a price point near resistance which was seen before (something like Double TOP pattern). But if Loss aversion wins, you commit to your stop loss and get out faster which creates a selling pressure force in a price point under the main support areas which is the result of triggering domino like stop losses.
I try to explain few different concepts together in a structured way. I would be glad to hear your opinion.
Why Rice Prices Determine the Direction of Interest Rates?Recently, I received questions asking my opinion on their borrowing cost, if they should go for fixed or float rates. We somehow know there is inflation, but not exactly sure how long it will last and how bad it will get. Because higher inflation leads to higher interest rates.
While I cannot advise them as I do not have a banking license to do so. However, I can point them to the commodity markets, I hope by doing so, it can help them to understand and read into the direction of interest rates with greater clarity.
Background on edible commodities:
Rice is a staple in the diets of more than half of the world’s population, especially in Latin America, Asia, and the Middle East. Annual production of milled rice tops 480 million metric tons, which makes it the third most-produced grain in the world after corn and wheat.
An increase in rice prices or edible commodities, it will really add pressure to the existing global inflationary pressure. Hardship will be more intense especially compare to other commodities like crude oil.
In short, people can still live with some inconvenience without cars, but not without food.
Therefore, when food prices become much more expensive, the central banks immediate and urgent measures is to counter it by rising interest rates.
Content:
. Why edible commodities determine the direction of interest rates?
. Technical studies
. How to hedge or buy them?
Rice Market:
91 Metric Tons
$0.005 = US$10
Example -
$0.01 = US$20
$18.00 = 1800 x US$20 = US$18,000
From $18 to $19 = US$10,000
If you are trading this market for the short-term, do remember to use live data than delay ones.
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
Specific Trendline to Determine the Direction of any MarketHow to identify the specific points for trendline to determine the direction of the market? In this example, I am using the Nasdaq index.
You can use this trendline technique to any markets because its principles in this tutorial are applicable throughout whether to an individual stock, indices or even commodities.
I am going to introduce the primary and secondary trendlines, I hope after this tutorial, it will bring greater clarity in how you can deploy them.
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
This method I just shared, it can be applied to any market and any timeframe, be it the minute chart or the weekly chart.
Micro E-Mini Nasdaq
0.25 = US$0.50
1.00 = US$2
Intra-Day Trading TheoryTrading opinions can be made in a very concrete or a structured manner just like how investors study into the financial numbers of the stock they are about to invest into.
Short-term traders also have its numbers they study into, it is the price behaviours or the price data of the instrument they are trading. When these data are converted into a pictorial format, it becomes a chart.
And I am going to share with you a simple illustration on intra-day trading using trendline and divergence, to derive entries.
You will find how this can be done in a very structured manner and you don’t have to guess too much into it.
I have included some links below on my previous videos on trendlines and divergence.
The first rule:
The first about intra-day trading theory is we have to acknowledge the word “intra-day”, meaning all trades are done within the day itself, and we will have to square off all our positions before the market closes. This is Because we do not wish to carry any risks overnight with unexpected gaps.
Micro E-Mini Nasdaq
0.25 = US$0.50
1.00 = US$2
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
Is this recent rally a bull rebound of a bear retracement? To make an assessment if the market has turned bear, during the closing second quarter on 29th June 2022, we discussed on the topic “Using S&P to Identify Recession
and on the 19 Jul, 2 weeks ago the tutorial posted here, we studied and expecting this current rebound, topic “Nasdaq a leading indicator of Dow Jones, S&P & Russell”.
In today’s tutorial, I thought of doing a recap between the two videos and explore if the current market and its development, if it is a bull rebound heading to break another new all-time high or if it is a bear retracement?
I have included both the video links below.
Before we get into this topic, please also take some time to read through the disclaimer in the description box below.
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
Tutorial example:
Micro E-Mini Nasdaq
0.25 = US$0.50
1.00 = US$2
(12,900 - 11,900) x US$2
=US$2,000
(Note: Opposite is also true)
• During the closing second quarter in June, on 29 Jun - “Using S&P to Identify Recession
• On the 19 Jul, 2 weeks ago - “Nasdaq a leading indicator of Dow Jones, S&P & Russell”
Can Interest Rate Be Traded Or Invested?How can we participate in the rise and fall of interest rate? Firstly, we need to understand the difference between interest rate and yield.
Interest rates are a benchmark for borrowers whereas yield is for investors or lenders.
• Interest rates are the fees charged, as a percentage from a lender for a loan.
• Yield is the percentage of earnings a person receives for lending money.
Both move in tandem together, meaning if yield moves higher, interest rates will follow.
Discussion:
• Direction of the Yield in the short-term and
• Direction of the Yield in the long-term
Divergence in a bull market means the bull is losing its momentum, keep a look-out for trigger points that may cause further stress to the market.
Micro 10-Year Yield Futures
1/10 of 1bp = US$1 or
0.001% = US$1
3.000% to 3.050% = US$50
3.000% to 4.000% = US$1,000
Note:
Micro Treasury futures are not micro-sized U.S. Treasury securities. They convey no rights of ownership, nor or they pay or accrue interest.
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
Market Range - What are they trying to tell us?When the market range, it is telling us they are lost with the main direction. And we are seeing that between all the US major stock indices and many stocks since the second week of May. Prices basically still trading around the same price since then.
In today’s tutorial, we will discuss:
• How to identify when market started to enter into a range and
• Which direction will it ultimately break away from a range market?
The concept of “Less is More”
When we trade into a contract that is within our means, we will be able to focus on trade set-up that is so helpful for entry, stop loss and profit taking than trying to manage our emotions as we have over traded.
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
U.S. Bonds & Stocks is ready for a rebound, why?One of the ways to determine U.S. stocks and indices’ direction in the long-term is to also know where the U.S. bonds markets are heading. Why?
This is because the US bonds, its market capitalization can be as large as all the U.S. stocks market combined; therefore, it is also as important to also track its direction.
In the macro trend over generations, the bonds move in tandem with the stocks market, meaning if bonds are heading up, the stocks market will likely follow.
• Where is the main trend of the 30 Years T-Bond?
• Why is the stocks market due for a rebound in the coming week?
For this demonstration, I am using the CBOT U.S. 30 years T Bond Futures. If you are interested to research and explore into other treasuries tenures and the yield curve, under symbol search, Futures tab – search for Bonds, Notes or Yields.
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
Using S&P to Identify RecessionInstead of waiting for NBER to officially declare the confirmation of recession, an alternative way to identify is using the U.S. indices quarterly chart, especially the S&P.
Typically, economists call a recession when GDP has declined for two consecutive quarters.
A committee at the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) is responsible for officially declaring when recessions start and end.
Why I favour S&P over Dow Jones and Nasdaq?
It has 500 companies from the largest to the smallest and from various industries. It is commonly use to benchmark for stock portfolio performance in America, a much wider and broader measurement. Whereas Nasdaq is Tech heavy and Dow Jones with too limited stocks of 30.
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
2 Steps in Drawing a Downtrend Channel A buying strategy in a downtrend.
How to identify buying opportunity in a downtrend?
Not my preference to buy in a downtrend, but that does not mean we should avoid it when buying opportunity arises.
Recognizing it is a downtrend, we keep our buy position short-term; as we are going against the trend.
Discussion: Rules in constructing a downtrend parallel trendline
Rule 1 – First the downtrend line
Rule 2 – Then, its parallel
Disclaimer:
• What presented here is not a recommendation, please consult your licensed broker.
• Our mission is to create lateral thinking skills for every investor and trader, knowing when to take a calculated risk with market uncertainty and a bolder risk when opportunity arises.
EUR/USD - Prediction of price movementThere is a W1 Medium Force that is offering a chance for an entry.
This entry is a D1 game opportunity. However there is a way to get in at the market structure level in order to convert the D1 SL into a H1/H2 SL.
I am showing you that 'around' 1.1800, you need to get in a long position, and hold it till 1.1970.
This offers a Reward Risk around 10:1.
Psych Hack #0007 - decision-making - it's what we do. Everybody - I mean everybody - who is actively trading has to make decisions. Entry points, exit points, trailing stops, stop-losses and so on - they all involve decisions. But what affects the integrity of our decision-making ? Some say we don't need to make decisions, once we follow a mechanical trading plan. I disagree 100%. If everybody could follow a mechanical trading plan and be millionaires it would have happened already - it ain't happening! End of.
I say that our decisions are made in our heads - our brains, our minds. I say that I (we) need to know about the pitfalls in decision-making - pitfalls that may affect our minds.
I'm sharing some things I've learned with others. These may not be of relevance to everybody. However, as the hard evidence shows that between 75 and 90% of all traders lose money consistently, I think it should be of relevance to a majority.
Declaration : None of this is advice - even if so construed. Opinions on the two charts shown are not be relied upon. Your losses are entirely your own.